FTXL vs SMH

First Trust Nasdaq Semiconductor ETF against VanEck Semiconductor ETF: cost, size, returns, what they hold and how much of it is the same.

Overlap by weight
60%
18 shared positions
Fee gap
25 bp
SMH is cheaper
1-year return gap
29.2 pts
FTXL is ahead
Larger fund
SMH
$65.7B

Side by side

FTXLSMH
FundFirst Trust Nasdaq Semiconductor ETFVanEck Semiconductor ETF
IssuerFirst TrustVanEck
CategorySemiconductorsSemiconductors
Expense ratio0.60%0.35%
Assets$1.2B$65.7B
Average daily dollar volume$40M$4.3B
ListedSep 20, 2016Dec 20, 2011
FrenzyCap score5983
1-month return−5.3%−3.7%
3-month return−3.6%−3.4%
Year to date+70.0%+49.9%
1-year return+87.2%+57.9%
30-day volatility39.6%33.1%
Worst drawdown, 1 year−32.6%−24.6%
Trailing 12-month yield0.08%0.20%
Holdings3827
Top 10 weight60.0%67.9%
Look-through P/E37.137.9
Holdings vs fair value+9.8%+4.2%
Holdings above 200-day average53%73%
Net flow, latest 3 reported months−$114M thru Jun 2026+$4.5B thru Jun 2026
30-day implied volatility45.6%38.3%
Holdings as ofas of Oct 16, 2026issuer dataas of Oct 15, 2026issuer data

Returns are price returns and exclude distributions. Flows are each fund's own latest reported months and may not cover the same period.

Largest shared holdings

83% of FTXL · 76% of SMH
HoldingFTXLSMH
NVDA7.78%20.06%
AVGO7.12%5.55%
MU7.36%4.68%
AMD4.51%5.57%
ADI4.38%4.49%
MRVL4.32%4.44%
TXN4.25%4.95%
INTC8.06%4.16%
QCOM8.10%3.93%
KLAC3.79%4.42%
AMAT3.58%4.25%
LRCX3.51%4.07%
MPWR1.87%1.20%
TER3.00%1.17%
NXPI4.10%1.07%
MCHP3.13%0.81%
ALAB0.56%1.04%
ON3.90%0.50%

Sector mix of the stock holdings

SectorFTXLSMHGap
Technology92.7%91.5%+1.2%
Industrials4.4%8.5%−4.1%
Materials2.4%0.0%+2.4%
Communication Services0.4%0.0%+0.4%

More: full overlap table · FTXL holdings · SMH holdings

Fund data comes from each fund's SEC filings and issuer disclosures and is shown with the date it is as of. SEC portfolio and flow filings become public about 60 days after the period they cover. Nothing here is investment advice; see Terms.